Back Roads Living

Butterfinger Poke Cake A Chocolatey Delight


Butterfinger Poke Cake

This butterfinger poke cake is one of those dishes that you will come back for seconds and thirds if you can't restrain yourself!

I first thought as I was putting this together that it would be another one of those mediocre cakes that sits around for a while and most of it gets eaten then a little gets thrown out.

Was I ever wrong!  Not this one, I had seconds and the wife loves this too. 

This cake is as easy to make as any other poke cake I have ever undertaken.  The topping makes this sweet and has a touch of a salty taste as well. 

For an all around dessert, give this butterfinger poke cake try!  I don’t think you will be disappointed! 


1 Chocolate Box cake

1 Jar of caramel topping

1 Can sweet condensed milk

1 Tub whipped cream topping (Cool Whip will do)

4 plus butterfinger candy bars. Add as many as you like per your taste. (Full sized bars)


  • Mix the box cake and bake per directions. 
  • Just before the cake is ready to come out of the oven mix the caramel topping and sweet condensed milk together.
  • While the cake is still hot, poke holes in it approx. 1” deep and 1” apart.
  • Pour the mix of sweet condensed milk and caramel topping over the cake slowly. (Give the mix time to run down into the holes).
  • Allow the cake to completely cool.
  • Spread the tub of cool whip over the top of the cake.
  • Crush 4 or more regular sized butterfinger candy bars and sprinkle over the cool whip.

Note, I just used a rolling pin to crush my bars in their packages. I used the mini bars but you can use any kind you like. There is really no limit of bars. Use as much or little as you like for your taste. The number above is a standard number for this cake.

We cut and ate ours as soon as we added the butterfinger candy bars. It was very good and tasty and more moist than a regular cake because of the caramel and sweetened condensed milk.

We found it very satisfying and we think you will too!

This is a cake we will make often!

If you like this butterfinger poke cake you will be sure to love our Butterfinger Pie!

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Leave a Comment:

Add Your Reply